Quick Answer: Section 231 of Israel's Insolvency and Economic Rehabilitation Law 5778-2018 sets a fixed order of payment. Creditors with a fixed charge are paid from their collateral first. Next come the costs of the proceeding, then preferential debts (mainly employees' wages and certain tax amounts), then holders of a floating charge, who can take no more than 75% of the proceeds of the assets it covers. Ordinary unsecured creditors share what is left pro rata, followed by post-order interest, deferred debts and finally shareholders. A foreign creditor ranks exactly like an Israeli one, but has to file a proof of debt within six months of publication of the insolvency order.

A foreign supplier, lender or investor usually learns about an Israeli counterparty's insolvency late, and then wants to know whether there is any point in filing a claim. The answer depends almost entirely on which rank the claim falls into. An unsecured trade debt waits behind several layers of claims, and the size of those layers, more than the size of the estate, decides whether anything reaches the unsecured pool.

This guide sets out the ranking under the 2018 law, with section numbers, and covers what a creditor outside Israel has to do to get paid. For the wider process (opening orders, trustees, rehabilitation plans), see our guide to Israeli company insolvency for foreign creditors.

1. The Law and Who Runs the Process

The Insolvency and Economic Rehabilitation Law 5778-2018 (Chok Chadlut Pira'on VeShikum Kalkali) took effect on 15 September 2019 and replaced the Bankruptcy Ordinance and the liquidation chapters of the Companies Ordinance. It applies to proceedings opened on or after that date. Under section 373, cases that were already pending continue under the old law.

One statute now covers both companies and individuals. The court issues an opening order (tzav pticha) and appoints a trustee (ne'eman), who collects the assets, decides on claims and distributes the money. The government official overseeing these proceedings is the Commissioner of Insolvency and Economic Rehabilitation Proceedings at the Ministry of Justice, the office formerly known as the Official Receiver (HaKones HaRasmi). Small individual cases below a statutory debt threshold are handled by the Enforcement and Collection Authority instead.

The ranking rules are in Part 4, Chapter 5 of the law (sections 231 to 242). The rules on secured creditors, including the floating-charge limit, follow in Chapter 6 from section 243.

2. The Order of Payment at a Glance

Section 231 lists the ranks. Each rank is paid in full before the next one receives anything:

  1. Fixed-charge creditors, from the proceeds of their collateral (sections 243 onward).
  2. Expenses of the proceeding (section 233), including the trustee's fees and the costs of running the estate.
  3. Preferential debts (section 234), in the internal order the section sets.
  4. Floating-charge creditors, subject to the 75% cap in section 244.
  5. General (unsecured) debts (section 235), with indexation and basic interest up to the date of the order.
  6. Additional interest (section 236): interest for the period after the order, and late-payment surcharges from before it.
  7. Deferred debts (section 237), such as fines and certain shareholder claims.

Under section 232, creditors in the same rank are paid pro rata with no preference among them. If anything remains after all of this, section 242 returns it to the individual debtor or, for a company, to its shareholders.

3. Fixed and Floating Charges

Fixed charges

A creditor with a fixed charge (shi'abud kavu'a) over a specific asset, such as a mortgage on land or a pledge over a named bank account or piece of equipment, is paid from that asset ahead of everyone else. If the collateral sells for more than the debt, the surplus goes into the general estate. If it sells for less, the shortfall becomes an ordinary unsecured claim.

Secured status still requires paperwork. Section 210(d) requires a fixed-charge holder to describe the collateral and estimate its value in its proof of debt, and under section 247(a) a secured creditor must file a claim before, or together with, notice of its intention to enforce. In a rehabilitation proceeding, section 245 bars enforcing a fixed charge without the court's approval.

Floating charges and the 25% carve-out

A floating charge (shi'abud tzaf) over a company's changing pool of assets used to be a lender's strongest tool. The 2018 law cut it back in two ways:

  • It ranks below expenses and preferential debts. If the unencumbered assets cannot cover those two ranks, they are paid out of the floating-charge assets (sections 233(c) and 234(b)).
  • It is capped at 75%. Under section 244(a)(2), the floating-charge holder can recover no more than 75% of the net proceeds of the assets the charge covers. The remaining 25% goes to the general unsecured creditors, and the holder's unpaid balance joins them as an unsecured claim. Section 244(a)(1) also limits the charge to assets the debtor held when the order was issued, plus their proceeds.

For a foreign trade creditor this carve-out matters a great deal. Even where a bank holds a floating charge over everything a company owns, a quarter of the proceeds of those assets is reserved for creditors like you.

Registration

A charge granted by an Israeli company must be registered with the Companies Registrar within 21 days of its creation under sections 178 and 179 of the Companies Ordinance [New Version] 5743-1983. An unregistered charge is void against the trustee and the other creditors. A pledge granted by an individual or another non-company debtor is registered with the Registrar of Pledges (Rasham HaMashkonot) under the Pledges Law 5727-1967. Both registries sit within the Israeli Corporations Authority, and both can be searched and used online through gov.il.

4. Expenses and Preferential Debts

The expenses of the proceeding come first after fixed charges. Section 39 leaves the trustee's pay to regulations, so there is no single percentage that applies in every case.

Section 234(a) then lists the preferential debts. The list is closed, and it is paid in this order:

  1. Employees' wages and severance pay, net of what the National Insurance Institute pays them, up to a cap per employee. The statute sets the cap at NIS 25,630 for wages and NIS 39,945 for wages and severance combined, and section 234(a)(1) updates both every 1 January in line with the national average wage, with the new amounts published in Reshumot. The current year's figures are therefore higher than the statutory base.
  2. Amounts withheld and not passed on: income tax the debtor deducted at source under sections 164 or 170 of the Income Tax Ordinance, and National Insurance amounts withheld under section 342(c) of the National Insurance Law, that were never paid over.
  3. Maintenance owed under a judgment and due before the order.
  4. VAT, principal only, that arose in the 12 months before the order.
  5. Debts under a written payment arrangement of at least 12 months, signed before the order, for tax, National Insurance, health insurance or municipal arnona. Only principal counts, for up to three years of charges.

Anything not on this list is not preferential. Ordinary income tax assessments and older VAT, for example, are claimed by the Tax Authority as general debts, alongside commercial creditors.

IN PRACTICE
When an Israeli employer fails, the National Insurance Institute pays employees their unpaid wages and severance under Chapter 8 of the National Insurance Law (sections 180 to 194), within limits set by section 183. It then steps into the employees' shoes to recover what it paid. Section 192(a)(1) of that law says the Institute's subrogated claim does not carry priority. Those amounts fall into the general unsecured rank, beside your claim, rather than ahead of it.

Advertisement

5. Unsecured Creditors, Interest and Deferred Debts

General creditors take whatever is left after the first four ranks, shared pro rata. If NIS 2 million remains and proven unsecured claims total NIS 20 million, each creditor receives 10% of its claim, whether it is a local supplier, a foreign lender or the Tax Authority. Under section 235, a general claim includes indexation and basic interest up to the date of the order. Interest for the period after the order, and pre-order late-payment surcharges, are pushed down a rank by section 236 and paid only if every general creditor is paid in full.

Below interest sit the deferred debts in section 237: fines imposed on the debtor and, for a company, debts to shareholders that arise from their membership or that may be subordinated under section 6(c) of the Companies Law 5759-1999 or another law. A shareholder who lent money to their own company can therefore find the loan deferred behind every outside creditor.

What does not improve your rank

  • A judgment, Israeli or foreign. A judgment proves the debt but does not make it secured or preferential.
  • An attachment obtained before the order. Once a company's opening order is issued, section 29(4) makes earlier attachments void, with a narrow exception for certain tax attachments. Under section 218, an attached asset that has not yet been sold goes back to the estate, although the collection costs become a first charge on it.
  • Being foreign. Section 298 gives foreign creditors the same rights as Israeli creditors, and section 298(b) says a foreign creditor's claim cannot be ranked below general debts unless an Israeli creditor's equivalent claim would be.

Set-off can do better than a dividend

If you also owe the debtor money, section 255 may let you set your claim off against your debt instead of paying in full and collecting a small dividend. The debts must have arisen before the order and be connected, or come from mutual dealings in the ordinary course of business. Under section 256, you must notify the trustee within 30 days of learning of the order.

6. Filing a Proof of Debt From Abroad

No creditor is paid without filing a proof of debt (tvi'at chov), whatever its rank. The rules that matter for a creditor outside Israel:

  • Deadline. Section 210(a) gives six months from publication of the opening order. A debt from before the order that only crystallises later can be filed within 45 days of arising, if that is later (section 210(b)). The trustee may extend the time where the creditor could not file in time and justice requires it (section 210(c)), but do not count on that.
  • Notice. Section 299 requires individual notice to known foreign creditors, stating the deadline, where to file and that secured creditors must also file. Creditors the debtor fails to list may never receive it, so if you have significant exposure to an Israeli company, have someone monitor the insolvency notices.
  • How to file. Under regulations 120 and 121 of the Insolvency and Economic Rehabilitation Regulations 5779-2019, claims are filed online through the Commissioner's system, on the form published on the Commissioner's website. The system and forms are in Hebrew, so most foreign creditors file through an Israeli lawyer.
  • Decision and appeal. The trustee decides within 90 days of filing and no later than 30 days after the filing period ends (regulation 129(b)). A creditor can appeal to the court within 45 days of receiving the decision (regulation 131(a)).

Attach the contract, invoices, statements of account and any judgment, and show how you calculated the amount. If the debt is in a foreign currency, show the conversion clearly so the trustee does not have to guess.

In an individual's case, the payment plan under a rehabilitation order runs for three years by default (section 163(a)), and the court can shorten or lengthen it. At the end the debtor is usually discharged from the remaining unsecured balance. Our guide to financial rehabilitation in Israel covers that process.

7. Protecting Your Position Before Insolvency

Once proceedings start, there is very little a creditor can do to move up the ranking. The trustee can unwind transactions made in the run-up to the application:

  • Preferences (section 219): a payment or security that gave a creditor an advantage over others in the 3 months before the application, or 1 year for a relative of the debtor. Insolvency is presumed during that period. Defences include new value given at the same time and transactions in the ordinary course of business.
  • Transactions at an undervalue (section 220): 2 years, or 4 years for a relative.
  • Asset flight (section 221): transfers intended to put assets out of creditors' reach, up to 7 years back.

Security taken for an old debt just before the debtor collapses is the classic voidable preference. Protection works when it is built in at the start:

  1. Search the registries before extending credit. A Companies Registrar search shows the charges already registered against an Israeli company, including any bank's floating charge.
  2. Take security at the time you give the credit, and register it within the 21-day window. A charge given in exchange for new money is much harder to attack than one given for an existing debt.
  3. Get a guarantee from someone outside the company. A bank guarantee is paid regardless of the debtor's insolvency, and a personal guarantee from the controlling shareholder gives you a separate debtor. See our guide to personal guarantors in Israel.
  4. Limit open credit. Prepayment, letters of credit and shorter payment terms reduce what you would have to claim as an unsecured creditor.

IN PRACTICE
Consider a scenario in which a Dutch supplier ships goods on 60-day terms to an Israeli distributor, and the distributor enters insolvency proceedings owing it a large sum. A bank holds a floating charge over all the distributor's assets. The supplier has no security, so it is a general creditor. Its recovery depends on three numbers: the 25% of floating-charge proceeds reserved for unsecured creditors, the amount of preferential wage and tax debt paid ahead of the bank, and the total of other unsecured claims it shares with. If it misses the six-month filing deadline, none of that matters. Had it searched the Companies Registrar before agreeing the terms, the bank's charge would have shown up and it could have asked for a letter of credit instead.