Quick Answer: When parties to an Israeli arbitration clause cannot agree on who should serve as arbitrator, Section 8 of the Arbitration Law, 5728-1968 gives either party the right to petition the competent District Court for an appointment. The court will appoint a suitable person — typically a retired judge or an experienced attorney — after hearing both sides. Alternatively, parties can designate the Israel Centre for Commercial Arbitration (ICCA) as the appointing authority, which avoids court proceedings entirely.

Signing a contract with an arbitration clause feels like a sensible precaution. You agree to resolve disputes privately, without public court proceedings. Then a real dispute arrives — a construction project gone wrong, a joint-venture partner refusing to distribute profits — and the clause has to work in practice. The first obstacle is usually a question nobody thought to plan for: who is actually going to hear this case?

For foreign nationals doing business in Israel, that question comes up more than you might expect. Israeli commercial contracts frequently carry bare-bones arbitration clauses that say nothing about how the arbitrator will be chosen, because neither side imagined they would actually end up in arbitration. What follows is what the law provides, and what you can do when your Israeli counterpart refuses to cooperate.

Advertisement

1. Overview of Arbitrator Appointment Under Israeli Law

The governing statute for all arbitration in Israel is the Arbitration Law, 5728-1968 (*Hok Ha-Borerut*). The law was modeled on common-law arbitration principles and has been interpreted over decades by Israeli courts to create a broadly permissive framework — courts respect the parties' agreement to arbitrate and will intervene to make the mechanism work rather than letting procedural deadlocks kill it.

Arbitrator appointment follows one of three paths:

  • Contractual appointment: The arbitration agreement itself names a specific individual as arbitrator, or sets out a precise method (for example, each party appoints one arbitrator and those two appoint a third). If the named arbitrator is available and impartial, the process begins without any court involvement.
  • Post-dispute agreement: After a dispute arises, the parties may still agree on a mutually acceptable arbitrator. This is always the fastest and most cost-effective path and should be attempted before any petition is filed.
  • Court appointment under Section 8: If the arbitration agreement does not specify an appointment mechanism, or if the specified mechanism fails (a named arbitrator declines, or the parties cannot agree despite trying), either party may petition the District Court to appoint an arbitrator.

Israeli law does not require both parties to consent before a petition is filed. A single party's application is enough. You do not need your Israeli counterpart's cooperation to get an arbitrator appointed.

2. Reading Your Arbitration Clause First

Before filing anything, read the arbitration clause in your contract carefully. Many disputes about appointment arise from clauses that are brief but not entirely silent. Common clause formulations and their implications:

  • "Any dispute shall be resolved by a single arbitrator agreed upon by the parties." Requires agreement. If you cannot agree, Section 8 is the fallback.
  • "Disputes shall be resolved by a panel of three arbitrators, one appointed by each party and a third appointed by the two party-appointed arbitrators." Each side appoints first. If one party refuses to appoint, the other can petition the court to fill that slot.
  • "Arbitration shall be conducted under the rules of the ICCA." This pulls in the ICCA's own appointment procedure. Court involvement under Section 8 is then typically unnecessary.
  • "All disputes shall be submitted to binding arbitration in Israel." Nothing else. This is the clause that most often ends up at Section 8.

If the clause is silent on the number of arbitrators, Israeli courts and practitioners generally default to a sole arbitrator for disputes involving sums up to a few million shekels, and a panel of three for larger or more complex matters. The parties can agree on this after the dispute arises even if they cannot agree on the arbitrator's identity — agreeing on the structure first sometimes makes it easier to then agree on candidates.

Also check whether the clause specifies a seat (*moshav ha-borerut*). The seat determines which District Court has jurisdiction for Section 8 purposes. If the clause is silent on seat, the court looks at where the disputed contractual performance was to take place, or where the subject matter of the dispute is located.

3. The Section 8 Petition Process: Applying to the District Court

Section 8 of the Arbitration Law, 5728-1968 empowers either party to file a petition (*bakshas*) with the competent District Court when the parties have failed to agree on an arbitrator within a reasonable time. The petition is not an ordinary lawsuit — it is an application under the Law's specific procedural pathway, heard more quickly and without full pleadings.

The steps are:

  1. Establish the contractual foundation. Attach the arbitration clause to the petition and confirm it is valid under Israeli law. A written arbitration agreement is required; oral agreements are generally not enforceable in Israeli arbitration.
  2. Show that appointment efforts have failed. The petition should document that you proposed candidates, gave the other side reasonable time to respond, and received either a refusal or silence. Courts may decline to hear the petition if there is no evidence that the parties actually tried to agree first.
  3. Describe the nature of the dispute and the expertise needed. This helps the court identify an appropriate arbitrator. For a real-estate dispute, the court may look for someone with property or construction expertise. For a commercial debt dispute, an experienced commercial attorney or retired judge usually suffices.
  4. File with the correct District Court registrar (*mazkirut bet ha-mishpat*). The petition is filed at the court's civil registry, together with the applicable court fee under the Court Fees Regulations, 5747-1987.
  5. Serve the other party. The other side is served with the petition and given an opportunity to submit a written response and appear at the hearing.
  6. Attend the hearing. Both parties may appear and address the court on what qualifications the arbitrator should have and whether they have any objections to candidates the court is considering.
  7. Receive the appointment order. The court issues an order naming the appointed arbitrator. The order takes effect immediately and is binding on both parties.
In Practice: Under Section 8 of the Arbitration Law, 5728-1968, once the petition is filed with the District Court registrar, the opposing party has 30 days from service to file a written response. Courts in the Tel Aviv and Jerusalem Districts typically schedule the appointment hearing within 3–5 weeks after the response period closes. The appointment order usually issues the same day as the hearing or within a few days. The arbitration itself can begin once the appointed arbitrator confirms availability and both parties receive notice of the appointment.
Advertisement

4. What the Court Considers When Appointing an Arbitrator

An Israeli District Court exercising its appointment power under Section 8 is not simply picking a name off a list. The court aims to appoint someone who can hear the dispute competently and impartially, and whose appointment serves the parties' original intent in agreeing to arbitrate. In practice, courts weigh the following factors:

  • Subject-matter expertise. A dispute about a construction contract in Tel Aviv calls for someone familiar with Israeli building law, standard Israeli contractor agreements, and local practice. A corporate dispute about shareholder rights calls for a commercial attorney or retired judge experienced in company law.
  • Availability. The arbitrator must be able to dedicate real time to the case. Courts check that the proposed appointment does not create an unrealistic workload burden on the appointee.
  • Independence and impartiality. The appointee must have no current or recent professional relationship with either party, their counsel, or any significant witness. Israeli courts apply the IBA Guidelines on Conflicts of Interest in International Arbitration as a reference standard, even in domestic cases.
  • Language and location. If one party is a foreign national who does not speak Hebrew, the court may appoint someone fluent in English or another language, or at minimum confirm that simultaneous translation arrangements can be made.
  • Prior proposals by the parties. If both parties proposed the same person in pre-petition negotiations but could not agree on terms, the court may appoint that person.

Courts may also consult a list maintained by the Israel Bar Association (*Lishkat Ha-Orkhim*) of attorneys who have registered as available arbitrators. Retired District Court and Supreme Court judges are frequently appointed in complex commercial matters because they bring procedural expertise and are perceived as neutral by foreign parties unfamiliar with the Israeli legal market.

The Section 8 hearing is purely about appointment. The court will not evaluate which party has a stronger claim, and substantive arguments about the merits belong in the arbitration itself, not here.

5. Institutional Arbitration: Letting ICCA Make the Appointment

An alternative to court appointment — and in many commercial disputes a faster and more practical route — is to designate the Israel Centre for Commercial Arbitration (ICCA) as the appointing authority, either in the original arbitration clause or by written agreement after the dispute arises.

The ICCA, based in Tel Aviv, is Israel's principal arbitral institution. It maintains a panel of experienced arbitrators, publishes its own Rules of Arbitration, and offers an appointment service to parties who want institutional oversight without full ICCA-administered arbitration. The ICCA Secretariat can appoint a sole arbitrator or confirm party-nominated arbitrators on request.

Under the ICCA Rules, the appointment process works as follows:

  • Either party notifies the ICCA Secretariat in writing, attaching the arbitration agreement and a brief description of the dispute.
  • The ICCA provides both parties with a list of potential arbitrators from its panel, with brief profiles.
  • Parties rank the candidates or strike names they find unacceptable.
  • The ICCA appoints the highest-ranked mutually acceptable candidate. If no consensus emerges, the ICCA President appoints directly from the panel.
  • An appointed arbitrator must disclose any potential conflicts of interest in writing before accepting the appointment.

ICCA-administered arbitration is especially useful for disputes with foreign parties because the ICCA is a known institution outside Israel, its rules allow proceedings in English, and its awards are more readily enforceable internationally under the New York Convention. Israel ratified the New York Convention in 1959, and an ICCA award, like any Israeli arbitral award, is entitled to recognition and enforcement in all 172 New York Convention member states.

If your original contract does not name ICCA but you and your counterpart can agree on institutional administration even after the dispute has started, amending the arbitration arrangement is straightforward — a written agreement between the parties is sufficient under Israeli law.

In Practice: When the arbitration clause designates the ICCA (Israel Centre for Commercial Arbitration) as appointing authority, the ICCA Secretariat in Tel Aviv coordinates the appointment without any court involvement. Each party typically has 10–15 days to rank or strike candidates from the ICCA panel list. If the parties reach no agreement, the ICCA President can make a direct appointment, and the full process from first notification to confirmed appointment generally takes 3–6 weeks — often faster than the District Court route. The appointed arbitrator must accept in writing and disclose any conflicts before the first procedural hearing is convened.

6. Challenging and Removing an Appointed Arbitrator

An arbitrator appointment — whether made by the court, by ICCA, or by agreement — is not permanent. The Arbitration Law provides a mechanism to challenge and remove an arbitrator for justifiable cause (*siba mutzedeket*). This is a safeguard against bias and conflicts of interest that only come to light after appointment.

Common grounds for removal include:

  • Failure to disclose a conflict of interest. The appointed arbitrator did not disclose a prior or current professional relationship with one party, their counsel, or a key witness.
  • Demonstrated partiality. The arbitrator's conduct during proceedings — handling of procedural applications, communication outside the hearing, written rulings — reveals a consistent pattern favoring one side.
  • Inability to serve. The arbitrator becomes ill, moves to an incompatible jurisdiction, or is unable to dedicate sufficient time to the case.
  • Violation of the arbitrator's oath. Every arbitrator appointed in Israel is required to declare impartiality. A subsequent violation of that declaration is grounds for removal.

The application to remove an arbitrator is made to the same court that made the original appointment (for a court-appointed arbitrator) or to the appointing authority (for an ICCA-appointed arbitrator). The application must be brought promptly — waiting too long after discovering a ground for removal can be treated as a waiver. Israeli courts have consistently held that a party who continues to participate in arbitration proceedings without raising a known ground for removal will find it difficult to raise that ground later, either to remove the arbitrator or to challenge the final award.

An application to remove does not automatically suspend the arbitration. Unless the court grants an explicit stay, the arbitrator and the other party may continue with proceedings while the removal application is pending. If you need proceedings to pause, you must apply separately for a stay — it will not happen automatically.

Once a removal order is made — or once an arbitrator resigns or becomes incapable — a replacement must be appointed. The replacement process follows the same mechanism as the original appointment: agreement between the parties, ICCA appointment, or court appointment under Section 8.

7. Practical Guidance for Foreign Parties

Foreign nationals and foreign companies navigating arbitrator appointment in Israel face some practical challenges that Israeli parties take for granted. Here is what to keep in mind:

Before petitioning the court, send your Israeli counterpart a letter in writing proposing two or three arbitrator candidates and giving them a specific deadline to respond — 14 to 21 days is reasonable. If they ignore the letter or refuse without proposing alternatives, you have documented evidence that appointment efforts have failed, which the court will want to see.

Language matters more than people expect. Israeli court proceedings are in Hebrew. You will need an Israeli attorney to represent you in the Section 8 petition if you do not read Hebrew. The arbitration itself can be conducted in English if both parties agree and the arbitrator is bilingual, so it is worth raising the language question explicitly when the court is considering candidates.

Retired Israeli District Court judges are worth considering as candidates. They are widely available on the arbitrator market, courts appoint them readily, and they bring procedural habits that tend to reduce squabbles over procedure during the arbitration itself. For a foreign party who does not know the Israeli legal market, a retired judge is often a more predictable choice than a private practitioner, however well credentialed.

Check whether your clause names an international institution. Some Israeli commercial contracts — particularly in real estate, construction, and technology — reference the ICC or LCIA. If your clause names one of these, their rules govern appointment and a Section 8 petition is generally unnecessary unless the institutional mechanism itself breaks down.

Ask for written conflict-of-interest disclosure before the arbitrator accepts the appointment. Once a candidate is identified, a brief letter asking them to confirm they have no prior or current relationship with either party or their counsel is easier to send now than to litigate later.

If the other party is deliberately obstructing — refusing every candidate, ignoring deadlines, filing bad-faith court challenges — Israeli courts know the playbook. A Section 8 petition framed around clear obstruction typically gets a faster hearing, and courts can appoint without waiting for the obstructing party's response.